Oven-Broiled Graham Cracker S'mores

Classic s'mores made indoors under the broiler, with golden toasted marshmallows, melty milk chocolate and crisp graham crackers in under 10 minutes.

Eight s'mores with toasted marshmallows, melted milk chocolate, and sea salt flakes on a foil-lined baking sheet
Prep
5 min
Cook
5 min
Total
10 min
Serves
8

When the craving for a campfire treat hits but there's no fire pit in sight, these graham cracker s'mores come to the rescue. We build a whole batch on one foil-lined sheet pan and let the broiler do the toasting in a minute or two.

Each one gets a piece of milk chocolate and a halved marshmallow, so the flat sides stay put and toast to a puffy, golden finish. A second cracker on top holds in the heat, and the chocolate turns soft and glossy while you wait.

It's just three ingredients, plus an optional pinch of flaky salt if you like a little sweet-salty contrast. Keep your eyes on the oven and you'll have warm, gooey s'mores in under 10 minutes.

How We Developed This Recipe

  • The four versions we compared all lean on the same trio of graham crackers, milk chocolate and marshmallows, and the ones that use heat agree on a quick trip under the broiler, watched closely, just until the marshmallows turn golden. Where they split is format: cereal bars, a pressed crumb crust, a buttery toffee base and chilled sandwich bites dipped in chocolate. We went with classic stacked s'mores under the broiler because it keeps the graham crackers crisp, needs no campfire, and gives that toasted-marshmallow flavor in about two minutes. Halving the marshmallows was our own choice, since flat sides stay put on the chocolate and toast more evenly.
Advertisement

Why You’ll Love It

  • Campfire-style s'mores made indoors in under 10 minutes
  • Golden, toasty marshmallows with gooey melted chocolate
  • Just three ingredients plus an optional sprinkle of flaky salt
  • Makes a batch of 8 all at once on one sheet pan

Ingredient Notes & Swaps

Graham crackers
Regular honey graham crackers are the classic choice, but cinnamon or chocolate grahams work too. Full sheets snap cleanly in half along the center perforation into two squares.
Milk chocolate
Thin milk chocolate bars melt the fastest and taste like the s'mores you remember. Chips work in a pinch, but they hold their shape more, so press them gently into the marshmallow.
Marshmallows
Use regular large marshmallows. Jumbo ones are too tall to soften through before the outsides burn, and minis toast too fast.
Flaky sea salt
Totally optional, but a tiny pinch over the chocolate balances the sweetness nicely.
Advertisement

Tips for Success

  • Marshmallows can go from golden to burnt in a few seconds under the broiler. Keep the oven door cracked, watch the whole time, and pull the pan as soon as you see even golden spots.
  • If the chocolate is still firm after resting, set the assembled s'mores back in the turned-off, still-warm oven for about 1 minute. Thinner pieces and room-temperature chocolate help prevent this.
  • Halving the marshmallows does two jobs: the flat sides keep them from rolling off, and the shorter height lets them soften all the way through.
  • Build all the s'mores before you turn your back to the broiler so everything goes in and comes out together.
  • Serve them right away. Graham crackers soften as they sit under warm marshmallow.

Variations

  • Peanut butter s'mores: swap the chocolate pieces for regular-size peanut butter cups.
  • Dark chocolate and salt: use dark chocolate and finish each one with a small pinch of flaky sea salt.
  • Cinnamon or chocolate grahams: switch the crackers for a different flavor without changing anything else.
  • Microwave single s'more: stack a cracker, chocolate and one whole marshmallow on a plate and microwave for 12 to 15 seconds, until the marshmallow puffs, then top and press.

Storage & Reheating

Best fresh
S'mores are at their best within a few minutes of broiling, while the marshmallow is soft and the crackers are crisp.
Leftovers
Wrap leftover s'mores and keep them at room temperature for up to 1 day. Rewarm in the microwave for 5 to 10 seconds to soften the marshmallow and chocolate again.
Make ahead
Break the crackers and chocolate ahead of time and store them in separate airtight containers. Assemble and broil just before serving. We don't recommend freezing assembled s'mores, since the crackers turn soggy.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you make classic s'mores with graham crackers?

Set a piece of chocolate on half a graham cracker sheet, top it with a toasted marshmallow, and press another graham cracker square on top. The heat from the marshmallow softens the chocolate as it sits for a minute.

Can you make s'mores in the oven or microwave?

Yes. The broiler toasts a whole batch in 1 to 2 minutes with golden marshmallows, while the microwave puffs a single s'more in about 12 to 15 seconds but won't brown the marshmallow.

What kind of chocolate works best for s'mores?

Thin milk chocolate bars are the classic choice because they melt quickly against warm marshmallow. Dark chocolate, chocolate with fillings, or peanut butter cups also work well.

How many s'mores from one graham cracker box?

A standard box usually has three sleeves of about 9 full sheets each, which makes roughly 27 s'mores. Box sizes vary, so check the sheet count on the label.

How do you toast marshmallows without burning them?

Keep the oven rack about 6 inches from the broiler, halve the marshmallows so they toast evenly, and watch them the entire time. Pull the pan the moment they're puffed and golden in spots.

Recipe

Oven-Broiled Graham Cracker S'mores

Prep 5 minCook 5 minTotal 10 minYield 8 s'mores

Servings
Units

Ingredients

EquipmentRimmed baking sheet · Aluminum foil · Kitchen scissors · Oven mitts

Instructions

  1. Heat the broilerSet an oven rack about 6 inches below the broiler and heat the broiler on high. Line a rimmed baking sheet with foil.Tip: Skip parchment and wax paper here, since both can scorch or smoke under a broiler.
  2. Set out the bottom crackersArrange 8 of the graham cracker squares on the lined baking sheet, leaving a little space between each one. Set the other 8 squares aside for the tops.
  3. Add the chocolatePlace one piece of chocolate in the center of each graham cracker square on the pan. Sprinkle a few flakes of sea salt over the chocolate, if using.Tip: Room-temperature chocolate melts much more easily than chocolate straight from the fridge.
  4. Halve and add the marshmallowsCut each marshmallow in half crosswise with kitchen scissors. Set two halves on each piece of chocolate, sticky cut sides down, so they sit flat and stay in place.Tip: A quick dip of the scissors in water keeps the marshmallow from sticking to the blades.
  5. Broil until goldenSlide the pan under the broiler and broil for 45 seconds to 2 minutes, until the marshmallows are puffed and golden brown in spots. Stay right by the oven, and rotate the pan if one side browns faster.Tip: Broilers vary a lot, so start checking at 30 seconds the first time.
  6. Top and let the chocolate meltCarefully pull out the pan and gently press a reserved graham cracker square on top of each s'more. Let them sit for 1 to 2 minutes, until the chocolate turns glossy and soft from the warm marshmallow, then serve warm.Tip: The pan and marshmallows are very hot, so use oven mitts and let the s'mores cool a moment before biting in.

Notes

  • One graham cracker sheet makes one s'more, so this recipe scales easily up or down.
  • Broiler strength varies from oven to oven, so the first batch may need a little more or less time.

Nutrition (per serving, estimated)

Calories
160
Protein
2 g
Carbs
25 g
Fat
6 g

Saturated fat 3 g · Fiber 1 g · Sugar 15 g · Sodium 105 mg · Cholesterol 3 mg

Save to Pinterest

About the author

Caroline Webb

Caroline Webb writes desserts and baking: cookies, quick breads, bars and no-bake treats. Her recipes explain why each step matters and how to tell when a bake is done.

More recipes by Caroline